For years, open banking was discussed mainly as a data story. Customers could share account information with budgeting apps, lenders could check income more quickly, and accounting tools could pull in transactions automatically. Those uses were helpful, but they rarely changed how people felt about their money from one day to the next. The more consequential test is now arriving in a less glamorous place: the moment when a customer moves money into a financial product and expects it to arrive reliably, every time, without extra effort.
Funding is where many digital financial products quietly lose customers. An investment app can offer a polished interface, an attractive selection of funds and a simple way to set up a monthly plan. None of that matters if the money does not arrive. Cards expire, get replaced after fraud alerts and carry processing costs. Direct debits are dependable but can take several days to clear, which creates a gap between the date a customer intends to invest and the date the investment actually happens. Manual transfers depend on the customer remembering, which is precisely the habit that automation is meant to remove.
Variable recurring payments are designed to close that gap. Instead of approving each payment individually, a customer sets up a mandate in their banking app that defines what a provider may collect: a maximum amount per payment, a total over a period and how long the permission lasts. Within those limits, payments can be initiated without the customer logging in again every time. Outside them, the payment does not go through. The model sits between a one-off bank transfer and a card on file, offering the convenience of automation with limits the customer controls through their own bank.
Early evidence suggests the approach can work in practice. Trading 212 recently added automated bank deposits backed by a 97% success claim, using TrueLayer’s Bank on File service to fund recurring investment schedules directly from customers’ bank accounts. The companies attribute failed payments to insufficient funds rather than technical problems, and they report that the method’s share of recurring deposits rose more than fivefold in under four months. Those are encouraging numbers, although without absolute volumes they show reliability among adopters rather than the scale of adoption.
That distinction matters for anyone judging open banking’s progress. Success rates describe how well a payment rail performs once a customer has chosen it. Adoption depends on whether customers understand the mandate, trust it and see a reason to switch from a method that already works well enough. Many people have used cards for decades. Persuading them to authorise a recurring bank mandate requires a clear explanation of what the provider can and cannot take, and reassurance that the arrangement can be changed or cancelled easily.
There is also a commercial dimension. Card payments carry interchange and processing costs that can be significant for platforms handling frequent deposits. Bank payments can be cheaper to process, and the reported average payment size of more than 50% above the average card payment hints at another possible benefit: customers may be more comfortable moving larger sums directly from their bank. For investment providers, that combination of lower cost and higher value could make bank-based funding attractive even before customers notice any difference.
However, faster funding is not the same as better investing. A payment rail changes how money moves; it does not change the risk of what happens to that money afterwards. A recurring mandate makes it easier to keep contributing through market declines, which can support long-term discipline. It can also make it easier to keep investing without reviewing whether the plan still suits the customer’s circumstances. Providers that promote automated funding have a responsibility to make it just as easy to pause, adjust or stop contributions.
Consumer protection is a further consideration. Card payments come with established chargeback processes that customers broadly understand. Account-to-account payments rely on different protections and dispute routes, which many customers know far less well. As commercial variable recurring payments expand beyond the narrower uses already required by regulators, clarity about what happens when something goes wrong will shape trust as much as headline success rates. A customer who cannot see how to dispute an unexpected collection is unlikely to recommend the method to anyone else.
The broader lesson extends well beyond investment apps. Subscription services, utilities, savings platforms and lenders all depend on recurring payments that customers barely think about until one fails. Open banking will have succeeded when moving money between accounts feels as ordinary and dependable as tapping a card, and when customers trust the controls enough to set them up without hesitation.
That outcome will not be decided by technology alone. Banks need to keep mandate management simple inside their own apps. Providers need to explain limits and cancellation in plain language. Regulators and industry bodies need to settle the rules on liability and disputes so that customers do not have to understand the plumbing to feel protected. Account funding may lack the excitement of new data-driven products, but it is where open banking now has the clearest chance to prove its everyday value.


