Traditional Medicare leaves medical necessity to the ordering physician. If a doctor says a patient needs a procedure, Medicare pays, and any disputes get sorted out later in audits. On January 1, 2026, that arrangement changed in six states. Ten months later, we finally have data on how the change is affecting the businesses that deliver care.
The short version is that fewer procedures are getting done, and the practices getting paid are the ones with the cleanest charts. Let’s get into the specifics.
How WISeR works
WISeR, short for the Wasteful and Inappropriate Service Reduction Model, runs through December 31, 2031, in Arizona, New Jersey, Ohio, Oklahoma, Texas, and Washington. Under the model, CMS hired six private technology companies to review requests for outpatient services it considers prone to waste. The list includes:
- Epidural steroid injections
- Skin substitutes
- Electrical nerve stimulator implants
- Knee arthroscopy for osteoarthritis
The vendors use AI and machine learning to check documentation against Medicare’s rules, although a licensed clinician has to sign off on any denial. Practices can submit a prior authorization request up front or skip it and face a prepayment medical review instead.
Either way, someone checks the claim before the money moves.
Then there’s the detail business owners tend to fixate on. The vendors are paid based on how much they save Medicare, adjusted for performance measures such as provider experience. You don’t need a cynical streak to see why that makes physicians nervous.
What the first six months show
In late October, researchers from the University of Minnesota and Brown University published a research letter in JAMA, drawing on 310 million patient records from all 50 states. Compared with the rest of the country, use of the targeted services fell about 20% in the WISeR states. Epidural steroid injections, the highest-volume service on the list, dropped about 15% between January and June.
Here, two details should catch more attention than the headline numbers.
- First, the services on the list that hadn’t been switched on yet showed no meaningful decline, so the drop really does trace back to prior authorization.
- Second, the effect faded. For injections, the gap shrank from roughly 21% in the first quarter to about 9% in the second, suggesting that part of the problem was process-related rather than medicine-related.
Still, the researchers can’t say yet whether the care that disappeared was wasteful or needed.
Meanwhile, the rollout itself was rough. Records the Electronic Frontier Foundation obtained through a lawsuit show CMS raised concerns with four of the six vendors within the first three months, including case backlogs, slow decisions and, in Washington, blank determination letters. CMS now says no corrective action plans are active and all vendors are in compliance.
Even so, CMS deputy administrator Kimberly Brandt told a conference audience in October that “there are a lot of things about WISeR that are not working.”
Where the cost lands
A hospital system can absorb a 15% dip in one service line. However, a five-provider pain practice in Phoenix or Columbus usually can’t. Take a hypothetical practice doing 60 Medicare injections a month. Losing 15% of them means nine fewer procedures every month, before you count the staff hours spent pulling records and chasing status updates. And it’s happening just as Medicare’s 2027 fee schedule trims the conversion factor by 2.31%.
The most revealing number, though, comes from Virtix Health, the Washington vendor. The company told Nextgov/FCW that 63.7% of requests were approved on first review, and that the rate climbed to 84.3% once providers resubmitted with better documentation. In other words, about 20 out of every 100 requests flipped to approved, and nothing about those patients changed except the paperwork.
This gap is the business case.
In essence, every bounced request costs you days of delay and staff time you’ve already paid for, and some patients won’t wait at all. In a March feedback survey released by EFF, one Ohio provider described watching three patients in deep pain cry at the bedside while they waited to hear back on a spinal procedure.
What practice owners can do now?
Owners who come through this in good shape will treat documentation as part of the revenue cycle. Once an algorithm decides whether you get paid, charting stops being clerical work.
While the first move is boring, it works.
Track every WISeR request the way a sales team tracks deals: submission date, vendor response time, outcome, and the stated reason for any denial. Within a couple of months, you’ll see which orders and which providers keep getting sent back, and you’ll have evidence if a pattern needs escalating.
Next, build the medical-necessity story into the note during the visit instead of reconstructing it later. Conservative treatments tried, how long they lasted, functional scores, and imaging should all be in the chart before the request goes out. Practically, this is where AI solutions in healthcare are starting to shine the most on the provider side. Tools that draft notes while the physician talks and flag claim errors before submission are a fair answer to a reviewer that runs on AI itself.
But don’t forget, specialty fit matters too.
Pain practices currently carry the heaviest WISeR load, and generic templates often miss what reviewers look for. Therefore, having one of the best EHR for pain management with pain-mapping tools, opioid tracking, and PDMP-ready e-prescribing gives staff a head start on every request.
Last but not least, if you practice outside the six states, don’t assume this stays there. Internal CMS documents obtained by EFF point to plans to add services and a gold card program that would exempt highly compliant providers. Senator Elizabeth Warren wrote in September that records suggest expansion into oncology and cardiac catheterization.
On the other hand, a bipartisan House Appropriations amendment to suspend the model’s funding has advanced. Honestly, nobody knows how this ends.
So, what’s worth watching right now?
What I keep coming back to is that gold card. If CMS follows through, clean documentation won’t just get you faster approvals. It could get you out of the process altogether, and the practices building those habits now are the ones that will qualify.
So, yes, Medicare has put an algorithm between your physicians and your revenue. You can’t remove it, but you can make sure what it reads is complete. For a small practice in today’s world, that’s turning out to be surprisingly profitable work.


