Disability insurance is designed to protect your income when illness or injury keeps you from working. But many people are surprised when their claims are denied (even after paying premiums for years).
This situation is more common than you may think. For example, some policyholders have had their disability claim denied by Reliance, leaving them confused and without financial support.
How Long-Term Disability Claims Work
When you file a disability claim, you’re asking the insurance company to pay you a portion of your income because you can no longer work. Most insurers will require proof that your condition seriously affects your ability to do your job or any job, depending on your policy.
However, it’s not just about meeting the medical requirements. Insurance companies often try to avoid paying out large settlements. This means they look closely for any reason to deny a claim, from missed deadlines to minor paperwork issues. This is how they protect their profits.
In fact, statistics show how tough the process can be. This may explain why around 67% of initial disability claims are denied, according to the Social Security Administration. Many of these denials are for reasons that can be avoided with the right preparation. Understanding how the process works can help you avoid the common traps.
Common Reasons Insurance Companies Deny Disability Claims
1. Insufficient Medical Evidence
If your medical documents don’t clearly show how your condition stops you from working, your claim may be denied. Insurance companies need detailed proof like doctor’s notes, test results, and treatment records. A simple note saying you’re unwell is not enough.
2. Non-Compliance with Treatment
Failing to follow your doctor’s treatment plan (like skipping therapy or not taking prescribed medication) can result in denial. Insurers may claim you’re not doing your part to recover.
3. Condition Not Covered by the Policy
Some conditions, such as mental health issues or chronic pain, may be excluded from your policy. Pre-existing conditions may also be denied. It’s important to check your policy details before filing a claim.
4. Inconsistent or Contradictory Statements
If what you say doesn’t match your medical records or your daily activities, your claim could be rejected. For example, if you say you can’t stand for long periods but are seen walking around a shopping mall, the insurer may see this as a red flag, even if it was a rare day.
5. Independent Medical Examinations (IMEs)
Insurers often send claimants to their own doctors for evaluation. These independent medical exams may be biased, and the doctors may downplay your condition. If their findings disagree with your regular doctor’s opinion, the insurer may choose to believe the IME instead.
6. Missed Deadlines
There are strict timelines for submitting paperwork and medical records. Missing a deadline, even by a day, can result in automatic denial. Keep track of dates and make sure all forms are filled out correctly and submitted on time.
Conclusion
Getting a disability claim approved can be challenging, especially when insurers actively look for reasons to deny it. Whether you’re dealing with a disability claim denied by Reliance or any other insurer, it’s important to understand the process, follow your treatment plan, and submit strong medical evidence.
If your claim is denied, don’t give up. You can appeal the decision with better documentation, help from your doctor, or legal support. The more prepared you are, the better your chances of success.

